1969 Frederico Garcia Guitar for sale

by dennis kinnaird
(cookeville, Tennessee, U.S.A.)

1969 Frederico Garcia Guitar

This guitar is in good shape a 3 little dings on the front of the guitar. It has a really nice sound to it. I am asking $1,500.00

Comments for 1969 Frederico Garcia Guitar for sale

Average Rating

Click here to add your own comments

Nov 03, 2014
Rating

2 Good Ones, Marcelino Barbero and Hernandis Grand Concert
by: Anonymous

I LOVE my '69 Marcelino Barbero and '74 Hernandis Grand Concert. I certainly wouldn't pay thousands for them, but anyone who says they're crap guitars obviously hasn't played one of the higher-end Sherry Brener guitars. These guitars are on par with the very best of the Japanese guitars that cost into the thousands today. My Hernandis Grand Concert ($300), with new nut and tuners ($50), gives me 90% of the playability and tone of a Ramirez 1a ($10,000) at 3.5% of the price.

May 30, 2014
Rating

Screen postings
by: Allen Marshall

Just like the people who post damaging reviews of restaurants they have never eaten at, there is a self acclaimed Juris Doctor that must have an inferiority complex because all he does is slam everyone and everything. Please don't post anymore from this person who downgrades the website. I bought a 1967 Fedrico Garcia new and still have it. Sold my Fender Strat. and Vox Super Beatle then. Wanted to live a little longer after playing in the US and the UK. Most people don't even know what the 67 F. Garcia is. Just like the 2 year old Ernst Benz Watch I have. Still miss Jimi H.

Jan 15, 2014
Rating

i love my 1967 Federico Garcia
by: terry

Got mine for $150 at Music Go Round. It needed new tuners, so I went to a local music shop and the guy there convinced me it was garbage and sold me another one for $700. I was going to take the Federico (grade 3) back to MGR but I found I could not bear to part with it. It really does have a great sound to it, deep and resonant on the lower strings and crystal clear ringing tones on the trebles. The $700 guitar is a bit easier to play and has slightly finer sound qualities, but I love how my Federico Garcia sounds. I'd say if you're a non-professional recreational classical player like me, you should forget about labels and try out an old Sherry-Brenner guitar whatever its name is. Thanks to the very informed people who have posted some really good info on these guitars here. Great discussion!

Dec 10, 2013
Rating

Garcia Classical Guitar
by: Russell

I have a Garcia (grade 3) classical guitar, which I bought new in Brunswick, GA in 1975. I paid $150 (no case - I bought a hard case much later). The label states the top is Spanish Pine, back and sides are Indian Mahogany, neck is African Cedar, fingerboard is African Granadillo. It has rather handsome marquetry (label says it is Persian) around the soundhole, on the bridge, and on the headstock. The label clearly states that the guitar was assembled in Japan. I have never thought this was a fine guitar; the pine top with high gloss finish does not provide a big sound. But the guitar sounds and plays okay, is fairly good-looking, and is a good beginner or student guitar. I like it very much, partly for sentimental reasons and also because it is very comfortable to play.

Oct 16, 2013
Rating

Garcia/Hernandis Info
by: Jon Bartz/San Juan Guitar works

Adding to my previous comment: Since leaving my last post, I have garnered some additional information regarding "Federico Garcia" guitars, and have acquired a 1970 Hernandis 1A. In addition to my newly acquired Hernandis, I have in my possession 5 Garcias: 2 1970's #3s, a 1973 #2, a 1969 #2, and a 1965 "Federico". The number 3s are good,entry level guitars; the #2s are a definite step up and the unrated 1965 "Federico" is a much better instrument, obviously made by a different manufacturer, as the Garcias all have a "Spanish foot", whereas the 1965 "Federico" does not. A former employee of Jim Sherry's told a mutual friend of our's that he witnessed Jim Sherry pulling labels out of A batch of Contreras guitars and replacing them with the early "Federico Garcia" labels. That may explain the construction differences between the early "Federico" Garcias (circa 1965-1967) and the late "Federicos" 1968(?) to 1969, which were rated by number (the "Federico" name was dropped by 1970). As far as the Hernandis guitar goes, the #1, 1A and Grand Concert are all very fine guitars, modeled (and nearly identical to) the Ramirez 1A of the same time period. I also have a Vicente Sanchis and several other Spanish made guitars in my possession, but the Hernandis is far superior to them all in terms of balance and range, and I now use it for my main gigging instrument (I am the house guitarist at a local Spanish Restaurant), with my older #2 Garcia as a backup (it also has better balance and range than the Sanchis and the others). If anyone reading this post wishes to be a serious musician, I would NOT recommend a Garcia #3. A #2 will get you by for occasionals (if properly strung),but nothing real serious. A Garcia #1, or above, can be "tricked" into performing pretty well, but I see Hernandis #1s and above going for not much more. I paid $350 for mine (shipping included) on e-Bay.

Jul 07, 2013
Rating

Sherry- Brenner guitars
by: Anonymous

All you kind folks that own Garcia and Hernandis guitars via Jim Sherry of Sherry-Brenner in Chicago, made in Japan, but you insist are Spainish, sound better than Ramirez, etc, local luthiers say are worth a zillion dollars- God bless you. Obviously, if you like the one you have, thats all that's important. But to compare them to fine classicals just shows your ignorance or perhaps your failing hearing. No doubt some sound better than others, thats quite the norm for guitars,but to extoll the virtures of laminate sides and back, factory built guitars is absolutely ignorant. Perhaps in a few years when your experience grows, you will realize the stupididy of your present viewpoints. Or perhaps, you will remain on the outside looking in.

Jul 07, 2013
Rating

Federico Garcia 1969
by: Anonymous

I have a Frederico Garcia 1969 Number 2 mase in Madrid to sell.

Please contact me : ouilaam@aol.com

Feb 05, 2013
Rating

about a couple hundred
by: Anonymous

well since the guitar was built in Japan (not sure what you are referring to Frederico Garcia 1901-1969 since he sure as heck did not build your guitar!) try asking a couple of hundred on C list or the bay.

Feb 05, 2013
Rating

Enjoyed the argument but which way should I go?
by: David

I own a Federico gacia guitar 1901-1969 that is going up for sale in very good condition. which way should I go ? How much should I ask for it ? Make an offer.

Jan 14, 2013
Rating

Garcia
by: Anonymous

I was given a 1969 #1 Frederico Garcia (Sherry-Brenner) around 1974 and even now it rings like a bell.The wood grain is beautiful to look at.My fingers are to short to accomplish on its classical size neck its true potential.Can the action be adjusted and any suggestions on smaller neck guitars or luthiers for a guy on a budget maybe a trade.

Jul 25, 2012
Rating

Garcia/Hernandis/Sherry Brenner
by: Jon Bartz

I have read a lot of speculation and supposed facts about these guitars and Jim Sherry. It's almost all speculation and hearsay. Here are the facts: 1. several individuals have posted that they bought Garcia and Hernandis guitars from Jim Sherry during the mid to late 60's and had to wait for shipment. One individual claimed to have picked his up at an east coast seaport and claimed his guitar came off a ship of Spanish registry, and that the bill of lading showed point of origin-Spain(seems like an awfully expensive way to ship from Japan, via Madrid!), 2. In mid 1970 an additional label was added stating the guitars were made in Japan, 3. within the next year or so, the two labels were replaced with a single label that combined the previous two labels, 4. The Hernandis 1A is an almost perfect copy of a Ramirez, 5. Ramirez marketed their guitars through Sherry-Brenner during the same time frame. 6.Jim Sherry was well-connected in the Classical world (there are photos of Jim Sherry having dinner with Segovia and Christopher Parkening stated that it was Jim Sherry who convinced him to write his first instruction book). Jim Sherry did not disclose the fact that he was switching manufacturing from Spain to Japan during the transition period (which must have taken some time) and has been villified because of that and some other indiscretions. Further, there was a falling-out with Ramirez (who may have been directly or indirectly involved in the Spanish manufacturing/only they would know) at about that same time. I suggest anyone who is interested check out the U-tube battle of guitars between a Ramirez 1A and a Garcia 1A (too bad the Garcia wasn't a Hernandis). As for me, I own a 1965 Garcia (unrated), two grade 2's and 2 grade 3's and I want to thank those fine individuals who talk trash about these fine guitars (especially the do-gooder that sells the "buyer's guide),and have driven down their value. Because, without their efforts, I would not be able to afford guitars of equivalent quality.

Jun 19, 2012
Rating

garcia/hernandis
by: Philip Conrad

Well, just finished reading comments on my '09 entry. Interesting firestorm. Loved the tirades.Hey fellows, listen up. All I said is easily verifiable on Google. I was connected with a high end Guitar salon in the 70's that dealt with Sherry-Brenner and soon found out the truth behind these guitars and another phony product he peddled called Marcelino Barbero. Still another of his phony deals- "Segovia" Model Ramirez 1a's. If you have friends and luthiers who salivate over these guitars and beg on bended knees to buy it, go for it. But if you ever play a fine guitar, such as a Blackshear, have a cardiologist standing by for them. I finally sold my 1a for $164.00 on EBay and was happy to get it. Buyer wrote back and wanted to return it by the way.

May 13, 2012
Rating

Flea Market
by: Alessandra

I just purchased one today at the Flea Market. It was love at first sight. It says Japan inside. Along with Garcia, and G.M.C. Corporation, with a serial #...
HE SOLD IT TO ME FOR $10.00 :) best $10 I have ever spent!!!!

Dec 31, 2011
Rating

relax
by: Anonymous

Some of the student model guitars made in Japan are quite good! Don't worry about the label. And for $70 buck it sure sounds like a steal.

Dec 30, 2011
Rating

Owner of a No. 3
by: Sherry Jacobs

My mother bought a No. 3 Garcia for my Dad at a pawn shop in Charleston sc for 70.00. Way back in 1972 before i was born. I was given the guitar in 2003, and i have always loved the sound of this model! No other acoustic guitar compares to it. Many of my friends leave there guitars at home when they come over just so they can play mine. I don't believe that they are pieces of crap under a false label, but if they are this piece of crap sounds great to me!

Nov 22, 2011
Rating

I love mine.
by: Corey Naughton

I bought my 1965 Frederico Garcia from the widow of a guitar collector. She said she just wanted to get rid of the guitars and wasen't trying to make big money. She said she wanted 100$ for each guitar and that she had no idea what they were worth. I picked up each guitar and hit an open E chord. I couldn't believe how this guitar resonated against my body. None of the other guitars came close. I bought it for 100$. Then I saw online it could sell for thousands and I never considered turn it around and selling it. This forum has kinda bummed me out but I still love my guitar. Who cares what the monetary value is anyway, this thing sound awesome.

Sep 10, 2011
Rating

Made in Spain
by: Anonymous

I have a 1969 Federico Garcia Model 2. Sides/Back are Mahogany, top appears to be a fine-grain pine. Probably made in Japan, but sounds and plays like a jewel. I've seen these on ebay for $300, but I would not sell mine. Rivals many of the multi-$1,000 instruments I've played over the years.

Jul 01, 2011
Rating

Priceless
by: Tech_Guru

I have a 1965 Federico Garcia. All my guitar buddies would part with their fingers to own one. No Martin or Fender can match the warm and rich tones. Will not part with it at any price unless it was higher than $4000.

Jul 01, 2011
Rating

Apr 24, 2011
Rating

it's the sound that counts
by: Anonymous

I have a FEDRICO GARCIA.
I wouldn't sell it for $3,000.
The Martins & Gibsons can't touch it's sound.
You'd be hard pressed to find many guitars that can.

Nov 01, 2010
Rating

Garcia 1973 Grade 1
by: Anonymous

The value is in the playing. I bought my Garcia Grade 1 new in 1973 and paid $300 with the hard case. And yes, the label lists all the different woods and the fact that it was assembled in Japan. Who cares??! This guitar has been my faithful companion ever since I learned to play on it. Everyone who has ever played my guitar has commented on its beautiful rich tone. I'm no Segovia, but I did have the privilege of hearing him play in Miami many years ago (he was in his eighties I think) and his guitar had the same rich tones as mine. Where other players have to use amplifiers on their own guitars, mine sounds beautiful on it's own. About three years ago I had the action lowered to make it easier on my arthritic fingers, but that is all I've ever done. I hardly ever have to tune it, even after restringing. I would never sell "my baby" and if my home ever caught fire I would rescue my husband, my dog, and my guitar (not necessarily in that order).

Jul 15, 2010
Rating

my experiences on Garcia
by: Malaga Guitar

--their sure is a bunch of opinions and mis-understandings about Garcia guitars. The Frederico Garcia guitar is a damn good guitar, the Garcia is an OK intermediate to starter guitar. If you put some 20 or 30 dollar strings on a Garcia and replace the tuners, saddle and nut most are ok intermediate guitars. Need one with a reasonably straight neck. The Frederico Garcia brand are really nice guitar and I would rate a little under Rameriez if both have some good strings and rest is equal. I have two Garcia guitars and two Federico Garcia in my small store and I usually stock same. The Garcias' sell for approx. 400.00 with new tuners, new full or partial finish, good strings and new gigbag. The Fredirico Garcia have new finish, new tuners, new nut and bridge and better strings. I sell these for 600 and up. I have no problem selling, except on no play forums like eBay where one can hear most anything from guitars and people!

May 13, 2010
Rating

H J Byron - Juris Doctor
by: Anonymous

Mr. H J Byron - Juris Doctor,

What law school did you go to? Your English writing skills are quite interesting to say the least. If you are a Juris Doctor then I am an astrophysicist!

The guitars are still worth $250-$500 max.

Apr 24, 2010
Rating

lots of Garcia guitars on this site
by: Anonymous

There are quite a few of these Sherry Brenner "Frederico Garcia" guitars on this site that have asking prices of $2000. $2000 for a cheaply made Japanese guitar with a phony Spanish label is a bit much. New classical guitar shoppers beware! There are quite a few high end quality guitars offered on this site by known makers such as Humphrey, Brune, Blackshear, etc. These luthiers are known for their exceptional work.

Apr 22, 2010
Rating

fake guitars
by: Anonymous

Isn't Sherry Brener the one who did some shenanigans with Ramirez guitars??

Feb 24, 2010
Rating

1970 Garcia
by: Jimmy La

I have a 1970 Garcia, Grade 1. The 'Federico' was dropped in 1970. The grading indicates the woods used. Grade 1 has E Indian Rosewood back and sides, Cedar top and Neck, Granadillo fretboard and bridge. The Sherry-Brener website indicates Brazilian Rosewood back and sides, Mahogany neck and Ebony Fretboard but this is not the case. It appears that there was some degree of misleading information on the part of Sherry-Brener as to origin. However, they are well made guitars. The website indicates of value of $3000 and I've seen people trying to sell them online for as much as $2500 and as little as $500. I paid less for mine in a pawn shop. You'd probably have to spend nearly $1000 to buy this level of quality in a new guitar. I love mine, it sounds great.

Feb 13, 2010
Rating

Still Waiting to Buy Your Guitar but, You are hidding!
by: Hector J Byron - Juris Doctor

Dear Mr. Philip Conrad

As an authority in guitars you stated in this respetable forum that quote:

"Garcia is a phony name/label created by jim sherry of sherry-brenner co. in chicago starting in the late 70s. The guitar is a laughing stock with people even remotely in the know. It's made in japan,very cheaply at that, with the 1a models sold new approx 250.00-if seller would like another one,he can buy mine that I purchased new."

Respectfully, I took your word: "I buy your phony Garcia Guitar that you bought new". Just send me a email to: hj.byron@yahoo.com ASAP. I send you the $200.00 + or - you had stated it is worth and save you get rid of this "phony" guitar that you discredit so much!

Respectfully Sir: The value of your word of honor is at stake at this forum, the ball is at your yard but, you does not respond!

I take your word of honor: I buy your Garcia "phony" guitar! Where is you now Sir?

I do not want to think that your comments are just "phony" "BS"!

Cordially,

H J Byron - Juris Doctor

Feb 10, 2010
Rating

I will buy your phony/cheaply Garcia Guitar!
by: H J Byron - JD

Dear Mr. Philip Conrad

I read your stements related the "SUPRA" issue quote:
"Garcia is a phony name/label created by jim sherry of sherry-brenner co. in chicago starting in the late 70s. The guitar is a laughing stock with people even remotely in the know. It's made in japan,very cheaply at that, with the 1a models sold new approx 250.00-if seller would like another one,he can buy mine that I purchased new."

Respectfully, I took your word: "I will buy your Garcia Guitar that you bought new". Just send me a email to: hj.byron@yahoo.com ASAP. I send you the $200.00 + or - you had stated it is worth and save you from this phony guitar that you discredit so much!

I will publish or deal in this forum!

Thanks in advance for your bona-fide acts and honesty. Yes Sir, you had just sold you Federico Garcia Guitar. Congratulations!

Cordially,

H J Byron - Juris Doctor

Jan 22, 2010
Rating

Could be woth it
by: John Mayer

Real ones have a red label. I own one. I bought it from a nun who taught me to play in New York in 1978. Between 1965_1974, this company had a very dishonest manufacturing process. A distributor in Chicago cooked up a plan to create these guitars in Japan claiming they were made in Spain. There is no such person as Fredrico Garcia.

What does your label say on the inside? Your guitar could be worth far more than $1000 or it could be worth $50.

Jan 11, 2010
Rating

still for sale
by: Dennis Kinnaird

I still have this guitar for sale. I will reduce the price to $1000.00. Call me @ 931-510-4769. thank you

Dec 16, 2009
Rating

Garcia's Make Beautiful Music !!!
by: Anonymous

You dont know what you are talking about.
I hv a Beautiful Garcia Made in Spain 1967.
Im not much of a guitarist, but people that hv played my guitar love the sound and the tonality.
Everyone who has played it has asked to buy it from me.
Someone who repairs million dollar Stratovarius
who also did a repair on my guitar wanted to buy it. He loved the sounds it produced.

Apr 19, 2009
Rating

philip conrad
by: don stone

philip conrad
made in spain in 1969

Jan 17, 2009
Rating

garcia guitar
by: philip conrad

Garcia is a phony name/label created by jim sherry of sherry-brenner co. in chicago starting in the late 70s. The guitar is a laughing stock with people even remotely in the know. It's made in japan,very cheaply at that, with the 1a models sold new approx 250.00-if seller would like another one,he can buy mine that I purchased new.

Aug 24, 2007
Rating

No Contact Details
by: Mike Bell

Hi Dennis,

Thanks for advertising with us. You seem to have forgotten to put contact details in your ad.

If you place your email address and/or your phone number in a comment box, I'll add them to your ad for you.

If you'd rather you could re submit the add with the contact details and I will replace your current ad with the new one.

Mike Bell

Click here to add your own comments

Return to Used Classical Guitars.